Where to Stay in Key West: A Complete Hotel Guide
Key West’s vibrant charm, with its pastel-colored conch houses and swaying palm trees, makes it one of Florida’s most sought-after destinations. Whether you’re seeking a romantic getaway, family adventure, or historic experience, this guide will help you find the perfect place to stay in paradise.
Luxury Resorts & Spa Properties
Ocean-Front Luxury
- Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection by Hilton
- Historic 1920s architecture meets modern luxury
- Largest private beach in Key West
- Two oceanfront pools and world-class spa
- Perfect for: Luxury seekers, beach lovers, special occasions
- Ocean Key Resort & Spa
- Prime location at Zero Duval Street
- Spectacular sunset views from every room
- Award-winning SpaTerre
- Perfect for: Couples, sunset enthusiasts, spa lovers
Upscale Boutique
- Marquesa Hotel
- Four restored Victorian mansions
- Two pools surrounded by tropical gardens
- Located in the heart of Old Town
- Perfect for: Culture enthusiasts, romantic getaways
Historic Inns & B&Bs
Old Town Classics
- The Gardens Hotel
- Named “Prettiest Hotel in Key West”
- Historic mansion with lush gardens
- Daily wine gallery happy hour
- Perfect for: History buffs, garden lovers, romantic couples
- Artist House
- Victorian mansion built in 1890
- Famous for its haunted history
- Wraparound veranda and period furnishings
- Perfect for: History enthusiasts, ghost hunters, architecture lovers
Family-Friendly Resorts
Kid-Approved Properties
- Hawks Cay Resort
- Multiple pools including children’s pool
- Kids’ club activities
- Spacious rooms and suites
- Perfect for: Families with children, multi-generational trips
- Parrot Key Hotel & Villas
- Four pools
- Multi-bedroom villa options
- Beach shuttle service
- Perfect for: Families, groups, extended stays
Budget-Friendly Options
Value Properties
- NYAH (Not Your Average Hotel)
- Flexible room configurations
- Multiple pools and rooftop sundeck
- Complimentary breakfast
- Perfect for: Young travelers, groups, budget-conscious visitors
- The Gates Hotel Key West
- Modern rooms at reasonable prices
- Large pool with food truck dining
- Free shuttle to downtown
- Perfect for: Value seekers, modern design lovers
- Key West Youth Hostel & Seashell Motel
- Dorm beds , private rooms
- Kitchen facilities available
- Mixed dorm and private room options
- Perfect for: Solo travelers, backpackers
- Ibis Bay Beach Resort
- Private beach access
- Free shuttle to downtown
- Authentic 1956 vintage resort
- Perfect for: Beach lovers on a budget
- El Patio Motel
- Quiet location in New Town
- Pool and garden area
- Free parking
- Perfect for: Road trippers, longer stays
- Blue Marlin Motel
- Located on Duval Street
- Pool access
- Clean, basic accommodations
- Perfect for: Location-focused budget travelers
Chain Hotels in Key West
Marriott Properties
- Marriott Beachside Hotel
- Luxury beachfront location
- Full-service resort amenities
- Marriott Bonvoy points eligible
- Free shuttle to downtown
- Fairfield Inn & Suites
- Modern, reliable accommodations
- Complimentary breakfast
- Located in New Town
- Budget-friendly chain option
Hilton Properties
- Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection
- Historic luxury property
- Beachfront location
- Hilton Honors points eligible
- Full resort amenities
- DoubleTree Resort by Hilton Grand Key
- Moderate pricing
- Resort-style pool
- Free shuttle service
- Located in New Town
Hyatt Properties
- Hyatt Residence Club
- Condo-style accommodations
- Kitchen facilities
- World of Hyatt points eligible
- Good for families and groups
Benefits of Booking Chain Hotels
- Points earning and redemption
- Predictable quality standards
- Corporate travel programs
- Member benefits and upgrades
- Best rate guarantees
- 24/7 customer service
Boutique Hotels & Guest Houses
Unique Stays
- The Saint Hotel Key West
- Stylish, contemporary design
- Located on Duval Street
- Rooftop pool and bar
- Perfect for: Design enthusiasts, nightlife lovers
- Authors of Key West Guest House
- Literary-themed rooms
- Adults-only property
- Quiet location near Duval Street
- Perfect for: Book lovers, quiet seekers
Location Guide
Best Areas to Stay
Duval Street Area
- Heart of Key West’s action
- Walking distance to attractions
- Best for: First-time visitors, nightlife enthusiasts
Historic Seaport
- Working waterfront atmosphere
- Numerous restaurants and bars
- Best for: Maritime lovers, casual atmosphere seekers
Old Town
- Historic architecture
- Quiet streets
- Best for: History buffs, peaceful retreat seekers
New Town
- More affordable options
- Local atmosphere
- Best for: Budget travelers, longer stays
Seasonal Considerations
Peak Season (December-April)
- Highest rates
- Perfect weather
- Book 6-12 months in advance
Shoulder Season (May-June, November)
- Moderate rates
- Good weather
- Book 3-6 months in advance
Off-Season (July-October)
- Lowest rates
- Hurricane season
- More availability for last-minute bookings
Practical Tips
Transportation
- Most Old Town hotels charge for parking ($20-40/day)
- Many visitors don’t need a car
- Consider hotels with shuttle service
Hidden Costs
- Resort fees ($20-45/day common)
- Parking fees
- Tourism tax (12.5%)
Amenities to Consider
- Pool (essential in Key West’s climate)
- Breakfast included
- Beach access
- Bike rentals
- Shuttle service
Booking Tips
- Book well in advance for high season
- Consider package deals including flights
- Look for free night promotions in off-season
- Check multiple booking sites for best rates
- Contact hotels directly for best rates on longer stays
Remember that Key West is a small island, and most attractions are accessible regardless of where you stay. Choose based on your preferred atmosphere and budget rather than location alone.
